If you want to discover your genetic history and where you came from... you’ve found the right place!

888-806-2588

Review of Science Writing and News Reports on DNA Testing and Popular Genetics

Native Americans Have Deep Ancestry in Europe: Yes, It's Official

Wednesday, October 30, 2013

Shocking, Long Overdue Revision to American Indian Genetics

By Donald N. Yates

The ecstatic waters . . .

Through their ancestral patterns dance.

—William Butler Yeats, "News for the Delphic Oracle"

We've been saying it all along but it looks as though geneticists may be forced by new findings in ancient DNA to admit that early Siberian people and present-day Native Americans both have strong roots in Europe, only secondarily in Asia. The nuclear genetic bomb was dropped by Danish geneticist Eske Willerslev at a conference on "First Americans Archeology," held October 16-19, 2013, at Santa Fe, N.M. The city that gave birth to the original atom bomb hosted a glittering roster of speakers in a venue better known for its turquoise jewelry, fry bread and avante garde art, including big draws Achilli, Adovasio, Dillehay, Gonzalez and Schurr.

The paradigm-shifting conference program will be commemorated with a book Paleoamerican Odyssey ($56) to be published by Texas A&M Press later this year.

Leaked reports in the news media focused on Willerslev's paper, "Genetics as a Means for Understanding Early Peopling of the Americas," which concerned the genetic sequencing of two ancient Siberians' bones discovered in the 1920s and now in the Hermitage Museum in St Petersburg. Analysis of a bone in one of the arms of a boy found near the village of Mal'ta close to Lake Baikal yielded the oldest complete genome of a modern human sequenced to date.

Of the 24,000 year-old skeleton that was Exhibit A, Willerslev was quoted in The Siberian Times, as saying, "His DNA shows close ties to those of today's Native Americans. Yet he apparently descended not from East Asians, but from people who had lived in Europe or western Asia." He added, "The finding suggests that about a third of the ancestry of today's Native Americans can be traced to 'western Eurasia.'"

The 4-year-old boy, who died 24,000 years ago in a homeland previously assumed to account for all the Indians who crossed a theoretical Bering land-bridge and founded the First Americans, had a male Y-chromosomal haplogroup of R1b, the most common lineage in modern Europe, and a female mitochondrial lineage of U, the dominant prototype in pre-historic Europe. As it happens, I am the same combination, R1b for male and U for female, as are innumerable others in our in-house study on Cherokee DNA, published, lo, some five years ago.

Whereas previous "peopling of the Americas" stuff has clung to and recycled haplogroup studies (sex-lines), the new shock research relies on autosomal DNA, total genomic contributions from all ancestral lines, not just male-only, not just female-only descent. The title of a blog from Eurogenes rightly emphasizes this:  "Surprising aDNA [autosomal] results from Paleolithic Siberia (including Y DNA R)."  

When we introduced the 18-Marker Ethnic Panel as an enhancement for our main autosomal product, DNA Fingerprint Plus, lo, again, these five years now and counting, we presented a map of prehistoric human migrations showing without any equivocation that "Native Americans," even as Cavalli-Sforza demonstrated two decades ago, were closer in genetic distance to Europeans than Asians. In fact, we claimed, on the basis of autosomal DNA, that having Native American I or Native American II was a result discrete and separate from East Asian, since Native Americans obtained frequencies of its occurrence as high as 80% and Asians were on the polar opposite of the scale, at the bottom for carrying it. Other methods frequently confused Native American and East Asian to the point of invalidity, particularly those products claiming to arrive at racial or ethnic percentages.

The moral is that autosomal DNA trumps Y chromosome and mitochondrial evidence, and only ancient autosomal DNA can truly explain modern DNA. Even one of the most antipathetic students of American Indian DNA, Theodore G. Schurr, seems to rethinking the rigid definitions that have built careers and won tenure for geneticists and anthropologists for decades. For the fanatics who have been toeing the party line on haplogroup Q, as set down by Schurr's company, Family Tree DNA, and its followers, we note the following statement of recantation or at least qualification, taken from the Santa Fe program:

"Tracing Human Movements across Siberia and into the Americas: New

Insights from Mitochondrial DNA and Y-Chromosome Data."

In this paper, I present genetic data from native Siberian and indigenous

populations of North America that help to address questions

about the process and timing of the peopling of the Americas. These

new genetic data indicate that Eskimoan- and Athapaskan-speaking

populations are genetically distinct from one another, as well as each

to Amerindian groups, and that the formation of these circumarctic

populations was the result of two population expansions that occurred

after the initial expansion of settlement of the Americas. Our high-resolution

analysis of Y chromosome haplogroup Q has also reshaped the

organization of this lineage, making connections between New World

and Old World populations more apparent and demonstrating that

southern Altaians and Native Americans share a recent common ancestor.

The data also make clear that Y-chromosomal diversity among the

first Native Americans was greater than previously recognized. Overall,

these results greatly enhance our understanding of the peopling of

Siberia and the Americas from both mtDNA and Y-chromosome

perspectives.

"Genetic genealogy" has become a fashionable buzzword, but to my knowledge few research studies or blogs and hardly any commercial tests authentically combine the two concepts. According to genealogy, I myself am about one-quarter Choctaw-Cherokee and three-quarters European. But genetics says my mitochondrial line (U2e) is Eurasian, even though I have traced it to a Cherokee woman who married the Indian trader Enoch Jordan about 1790 in north Georgia.  Estimates from other "genetic genealogy" companies for my Native American ancestry, and I've taken them all, range from 0% (23&me) to 8% (Family Tree DNA, AncestryByDNA). 

DNA Consultants, the company I founded in 2003, does not give percentages of ancestry by policy, but half my top matches in our autosomal analysis are Native American, and North Asian/Siberian is No. 1 in my megapopulation result, followed by Central Asian and Native American (and only distantly by Northern European). On an autosomal approach, if not haplogroup basis, my genes are Native American, which is how I self-identify. If I were to be pulled over for being a brown person in the state of Arizona, where I currently reside, and Sheriff Joe ran my DNA profile numbers through the system he would find that I am 15 times more likely to be North Asian than Northern European, and twice as likely to be American Indian than East Asian, European American or Iberian American (Hispanic).

Read the whole analysis of my personal genetics, with actual reports from various companies, in the Cherokee Results pages on the DNA Consultants website. You may also find an extended study showing what autosomal DNA can do at:

Reconstructing Your Ancestry and Parentage (blog post, March 14, 2012)

If and when geneticists get serious about identifying the European sources of the American Indian gene pool, and hopefully they will round up not just one suspect (Denmark?), I would like for those who get paid and promoted to study us to please consider the following points:

—First New Cherokee Data Published in More Than Ten Years (announcement, August 1, 2012) - in-house study described numerous instances of U, findings published in Donald Yates' Old World Roots of the Cherokee.

—Stephen C. Jett, who taught geography at The Ohio State University 1963-1964 and then at the University of California, Davis, serving thrice as Geography chair and becoming emeritus in 2000, current editor of Pre-Columbiana, has frequently pointed out that just because Native American haplogroups match Siberian haplogroups doesn't mean the population of either Native America or Siberia was the same in remote history as today. He considered this a big fallacy of Big Science.

—Constantine Rafinesque, whose History of the American Indians was the first and most comprehensive treatment of the subject, believed all the early settlers of the Americas came "through the Atlantic," and only beginning about 1000 BCE did the Iztacans and Oguzians (Central Asian Turkic peoples) arrive. See our blog:  American Indian and Turkic People Share Deep Ancestry (June 6, 2012).

—Canadian environmentalist Farley Mowat, the author of thirty-seven books, has constantly challenged the conventional knowledge that Vikings were the first Europeans to reach North America. In The Farfarers he describes the Alban people of Old Europe as visitors and colonists from the time when walrus hunters discovered the sea routes to the West before the Bronze Age. America's original name of the White (or Beautiful) Land is mentioned by Rafinesque and in Hindu, Greek, Egyptian, Mesopotamian, Arabic, Algonquian Indian, Irish, Norse and Chinese accounts.  See "An Interview with Farley Mowat" on YouTube.

—Cyclone Covey of Wake Forest University, among other historians, has noted that Clovis Culture appears fully formed without any antecedents in America, with the most perfect examples of Clovis points traced in a cline of occurence in archeological sites to the Atlantic Coast.

—The earliest Americans clearly practiced the same Mother Goddess religion elaborately documented in the east Mediterranean and Old Europe by Marija Gimbutas. Their ideas of matriarchy or gylany (in Riana Eisler's coinage) did not come from Asia. See Archeologist of the Goddess (webpage) and "Syncretism, Not Animism" (PPT), a presentation given at the Sandy, Utah conference, March 29, 2011.

—When customers of DNA Consultants with various degrees of Native American admixture have their European population matches analyzed, a frequent top result is Finland or Finno-Ugric or Uralic. This "false match" could be explained by shared ancestry between the present-day Finns (where U is the modal haplogroup) and ancestors of Native Americans coming from Europe. Consider taking the EURO DNA test ($99).

—John L. Sorenson and Carl L. Johannessen in World Trade and Biological Exchanges before 1492 (2009) document several plants that originated in the Eastern Hemisphere (not Asia) and traveled early by human hand to the Americas. For instance, Cannabis sativa (marijuana) moved from Western Asia or Europe to Peru by 100 CE, and mugwort (Artemisia vulgaris) was brought to Mexico from across the Atlantic Ocean by 1500 BCE. Both grow in profusion in Europe and temperate parts of Central Asia. Goosefoot (an important Ohio Valley Moundbuilder staple), cotton, coconuts, bananas, turmeric and North American myrtle likely took the same route. In the opposite direction, Mexican agave spread to the Mediterranean world by 300 BCE.

Archeologists described the recent news from Santa Fe as jaw-dropping. We expect that when the definitive report on the Siberian boy's 24,000 year-old genome appears in the journal Nature, where it is at press, their hair may fall out. At any rate, the European origins of Indians is going to be a game changer not only in genetics, but anthropology, archeology, government and, perhaps most significantly, in the self-awareness of millions of Americans who count Native Americans among their ancestors.

 
























Our standard world migration map had the story right years ago.


Comments

Don Danielson commented on 30-Oct-2013 05:36 PM

I can add no data, only my applause. There are, truly, more similarities among people than differences.

James Stritzel commented on 11-Nov-2013 03:03 PM

CONGRATULATIONS!! For vindication of what you and DNA Consultants have been in the forefront of for years. Still will be fierce resistance but the light of your leadership is starting to shine and grow in the ‘Official Establishment’.

I remember and still have a book from the early 1990’s “Giving Voice to Bear” by David Rockwell. In it he wrote of the similarity of how Bear is depicted/revered/hunted around the sub-Arctic. Briefly wrote about a circumpolar subarctic culture. That has stuck with me 20+ years.

Here with Eske Willerley’s “….genetic bombshell….” is validation of what must have been pre-Columbian peopling of Americas other than the orthodox version.

Thanks so much for your dedication, determination and achievements in the DNA Field.

Jim Stritzel

Anonymous commented on 14-Nov-2013 09:18 PM

I have a lot of Siberian DNA as well as a lot of Greek and Iranian DNA, but come from Black Sea area/Georgia. But look European. MtDNA is H1b. Mom's dad's Y chromo is R1b. We were supposed to have come from the Caucasus in ancestral times. Lots of redheads in the family. Curious.

Bill Hucks commented on 20-Nov-2013 05:15 PM

This is one of many articles I've read on the Siberian boy. You mention that his Ydna is R1b, however it is not mentioned in any other articles. I'm very curious to know if R1b has indeed, been confirmed. --That was reported in the full version of the scientific paper.


Please tell us what you think

Name, website, and email are optional; if we publish your comment, your name will be shown, and may be linked to your website if provided, but the email you enter will not be published.





Captcha Image


Recent Posts


Tags

New Mexico Harry Ostrer AP Colin Renfrew American Journal of Human Genetics Elzina Grimwood Holocaust Database ENFSI Arizona State University Y chromosome DNA crypto-Jews Ziesmer, Zizmor Zuni Indians Anne Marie Fine First Peoples single nucleotide polymorphism Charles Perou Old Souls in a New World Finnish people Epoch Times aliyah Johnny Depp Mark Stoneking Melanesians Irish DNA Denisovans breast cancer Holocaust mitochondrial DNA Eric Wayner Cajuns Jim Bentley phenotype Lab Corp American history Elvis Presley DNA Life Technologies Micmac Indians Hohokam Arabia Akhenaten hominids Walter Plecker Asiatic Fathers of America Chuetas Cismar William Byrd Austro-Hungary Marija Gimbutas Population genetics microsatellites Bering Land Bridge Muslims in American history Cree Indians Charlemagne IntegenX Douglas Preston Rich Crankshaw history of science Nayarit genomics labs Secret History of the Cherokee Indians education North Carolina Sasquatch Jon Entine DNA magazine Constantine Rafinesque Scotland DNA Diagnostics Center King Arthur, Tintagel, The Earliest Jews and Muslims of England and Wales Hohokam Indians Tutankamun corn Sea Peoples Elizabeth C. Hirschman David Reich Roma People Wendy Roth private allele alleles DNA Forums Wikipedia Early Jews and Muslims of England and Wales (book) b'nei anousim genealogy London Monica Sanowar Bode Technology Chris Tyler-Smith Rebecca L. Cann Anacostia Indians Society for Crypto-Judaic Studies Elizabeth DeLand haplogroup W Cherokee DNA Project Europe Austronesian, Filipinos, Australoid climate change B'nai Abraham human leukocyte antigens Etruscans ethnicity England Plato Stan Steiner Charlotte Harris Reese El Castillo cave paintings Pueblo Indians Sarmatians Russia James Stritzel forensics Monya Baker Jewish novelists Telltown Rafael Falk Epigraphic Society Y chromosomal haplogroups Victor Hugo Central Band of Cherokees Wales Genome Sciences Building Maui Italy Abenaki Indians mummies giants Silverbell Artifacts Middle Ages Signal Hill Black Dutch Native American DNA Test Havasupai Indians Sizemore surname Dienekes Anthropology Blog FOX News New York Review of Books Jan Ravenspirit Franz origins of art Kentucky Cherokee Nation of Oklahoma admixture Ireland Acadians Sinaloa familial Mediterranean fever haplogroup N Janet Lewis Crain When Scotland Was Jewish Robinson Crusoe Phillipe Charlier James Shoemaker Stephen A. Leon prehistory Terry Gross haplogroup R Arabic National Geographic Daily News El Paso Pima Indians University of Leicester Myra Nichols Holy Roman Empire Texas A&M University Science Daily, Genome Biol. Evol., Eran Elhaik, Khazarian Hypothesis, Rhineland Hypothesis Miguel Gonzalez National Museum of Natural History Nova Scotia DNA Fingerprint Test Navajo Anne C. Stone Sorbs Slovakia population isolates bar mitzvah haplogroup D Belgium Discovery Channel Albert Einstein College of Medicine Alia Garcia-Ureste haplogroup M Teresa Panther-Yates Mexico Algonquian Indians Jewish contribution to world literature hoaxes Alabama Ostenaco Virginia DeMarce surnames Asiatic Echoes Irish Central Black Irish Native American DNA ethics population genetics andrew solomon New York Times Iran gedmatch genetic memory autosomal DNA Richard Dewhurst Mary Kugler Jews Promega Patagonia Mohawk Bulgaria Yates surname haplogroup G genetics Tumamoc Hill religion Thuya INORA Cooper surname Theodore Steinberg George van der Merwede Kurgan Culture Riane Eisler Los Lunas Decalogue Stone Caucasian Tom Martin Scroft Israel Ananya Mandal Waynesboro Pennsylvania health and medicine peopling of the Americas Helladic art haplogroup E race Chris Stringer Gunnar Thompson Celts Eske Willerslev Joseph Andrew Park Wilson Kennewick Man Middle Eastern DNA Phoenix pheromones polydactylism Philippa Langley Hopi Indians Gustavo Ramirez Calderon Magdalenian culture Scientific American M. J. Harper China Bentley surname research Rush Limbaugh Paleolithic Age Patrick Pynes haplogroup H Majorca Cherokee DNA Comanche Indians Cave art Mucogee Creeks DNA databases EURO DNA Fingerprint Test Discover magazine Smithsonian Magazine Melungeon Union haplogroup T Tintagel John Butler Louis XVI Kate Wong clinical chemistry evolution PNAS Douglas C. Wallace occipital bun archeology Family Tree DNA Lithuania Anasazi horizontal inheritance Applied Epistemology Shlomo Sand North African DNA human migrations Jewish GenWeb megapopulations Maya Hadassah Magazine medicine David Cornish Moundbuilders Israel, Shlomo Sand anthropology Anglo-Saxons Wendell Paulson GlobalFiler Phyllis Starnes The Calalus Texts Cornwall Bradshaw Foundation powwows Horatio Cushman Jesse Montes Jewish genetics Zizmer rapid DNA testing Odessa Shields Cox Irish history Khazars Satoshi Horai haplogroup X Greeks Michael Schwartz Henry VII far from the tree Nadia Abu El-Haj Nature Genetics DNA Fingerprint Test African DNA pipe carving Current Anthropology ISOGG consanguinity news Gregory Mendel John Wilwol Luca Pagani Henry IV Richard Buckley oncology Panther's Lodge Publishers Melungeon Heritage Association ancient DNA Beringia Juanita Sims Normans Patrick Henry Early Jews of England and Wales haplogroup C Washington D.C. Cleopatra Tennessee Taino Indians Sinti Bigfoot Freemont Indians Smithsonian Institution MHC Leicester Hertfordshire Melungeons Timothy Bestor Zionism Alec Jeffreys mutation rate Donald N. Yates Old World Roots of the Cherokee Chauvet cave paintings seafaring DNA testing companies European DNA Tucson crosses Neanderthals haplogroup Z Bryony Jones Columbia University Pomponia Graecina French Canadians Phoenicians Echota Cherokee Tribe of Alabama Peter Parham Maronites Neolithic Revolution Panther's Lodge Stacy Schiff Melba Ketchum Sizemore Indians Oxford Journal of Evolution genetic determinism Gravettian culture French DNA Sir Joshua Reynolds Cohen Modal Haplotype Roberta Estes Asian DNA Arizona 23andme Stony Creek Baptist Church Hispanic ancestry Daniel Defoe Indian Territory family history X chromosome HapMap haplogroup B Mark Thomas Jalisco Olmec myths Michael Grant Hebrew inscriptions Nikola Tesla George Starr-Bresette Barack Obama haplogroup U Stephen Oppenheimer DNA security National Health Laboratories Cocoraque Butte research cancer Altai Turks Lebanon Kitty Prince of the Bear River Athabaskans Ukraine university of North Carolina at Chapel Hill Valparaiso University Ancient Giantns Who Ruled America bloviators Genex Diagnostics Ethel Cox Joel E. Harris BBCNews Ashkenazi Jews Rare Genes Tifaneg Turkic DNA Richard III prehistoric art Erika Chek Hayden Britain clan symbols New York Academy of Sciences Antonio Torroni Solutreans Khoisan Bryan Sykes statistics Salt River Charles Darwin mental foramen Puerto Rico Harold Sterling Gladwin Penny Ferguson Choctaw Indians ethnic markers Indo-Europeans Mildred Gentry Nature Communications Nancy Gentry Germany Kari Carpenter Kari Schroeder Great Goddess Tucson Bureau of Indian Affairs Gila River India King Arthur Douglas Owsley palatal tori Mary Settegast Thruston Tablet Dragging Canoe Basques Svante Paabo Tara MacIsaac Richard Lewontin Sam Kean Abraham Lincoln Clovis N. Brent Kennedy Bill Tiffee linguistics Egyptians Oxford Nanopore Native American Graves Protection and Repatriation Act The Nation magazine Keros Gypsies Carl Zimmer FDA Rutgers University Ripan Malhi FBI NPR Colima Melungeon Movement District of Columbia Jack Goins Ancestry.com Cancer Genome Atlas human leukocyte testing Amy Harmon immunology rock art Joseph Jacobs Ron Janke Wellcome Trust Sanger Institute personal genomics haplogroup J art history CODIS markers Navajo Indians Les Miserables Jews and Muslims in British Colonial America Virginia genealogy Peter Martyr Stone Age Ari Plost Colin Pitchfork Nephilim, Fritz Zimmerman John Ruskamp Mother Qualla Chromosomal Labs Bode Technology haplogroup L cannibalism Illumina BATWING Sonora ged.com epigenetics Robert C. Hyde Henriette Mertz Pueblo Grande Museum Romania Isabel Allende methylation Cherokee Freedmen Cismaru Hawaii Genie Milgrom Central Band of Cherokee metis Richmond California Marie Cheng Daily News and Analysis Barnard College Russell Belk Michoacan Grim Sleeper Brian Wilkes Science magazine Fritz Zimmerman

Archive